The judge denies when using AI recording to speak at an inquiry | Method

At the Federal Regional Court of the 4th region (TRF -4), a lawyer was reprimanded for using Artificial Intelligence (AI) during oral support. Instead of performing the arguments individually, he reproduced the recording with the AI ​​robotic voice, which was disrespectful.

At the end of April, in the session of the 2nd TRF -4 appeals panel, the appeal was held in the appeal to grant social security benefit. The case was revealed by Legal Portal Migalhas.

Roberto Vedana, who was authorized to speak, asked whether he could appoint IA in support of IA, which was allowed. However, he surprised the judges by inspiring the audio with a robotic voice that was fully reading his argument.

Asked EstadoVedana did not respond until the report was published.

The recording occupies five control minutes. In addition, the lawyer also requested additional second seconds to complete the reading. This attitude has caused discomfort among magistrates.

“Doctor, this is definitely repeated and unnecessary. I will ask you to cut your sound,” he said.

Later, the reporter of the case, Federal Judge Vicente Atade Janear, voted to continue the verdict on the appeal based on the reasons of the original decision.

The process was dealt with with a rural retirement request by insured. The judge admitted that she was working in rural areas, but she understood that she was inadequate for the rules of the family economy. According to him, the size and sales of the property have shown that it is agricultural activities with the company’s characteristics. Therefore, he voted against the purpose request.

Along with the reporter, Federal Judge Leonardo criticized the attitude of Castonho. “I feel disrespectful of listening to the recording of magistrates. To do this, to do this, to join the recording. I don’t come here to listen to recording. It is not enough.”