Can a “experience” with renewable energy cause blackout?

Advertisement

An article published in the British newspaper last week suggests that the massive darkness that left the Ibirian Peninsula to the dark on April 28, with the “experience” of the Spanish government.

Telegraph’s world economist, Ambrose Evans-Britzart, wrote that “according to the sources in Brussels, wrote that Spain’s authorities” study “until the progressive removal of nuclear reactors in Spain can lead to” renewable energies. “

He did not explain his resources or provide evidence to support his statements.

The allegations were resumed by the main Spanish and international media World E. E. And multiplied by users of social networks.

But a vision of covering the article reveals that it has been effectively published as an editorial, but not as a news article, and Ambrose Evans-Britsard is a regular telegraph columnist.

April 28, Point Pedro Sanchez to criticize the Energy Policy of the Prime Minister’s Socialist Government. According to a project agreed with Sanchez in 2019, Spain gradually removes its nuclear centers to focus on green energy sources in the next decade, which considers Evans-Britsart to be irresponsible.

In his analysis, Evans-Britzart cited the “evidence in Brussels” and confirmed that there was an experience before closing to Spain.

But later he says, “If this proves that blackout is a controlled experience, this information is confronted with the election of a political generation of Spain’s left of the Spanish (…) if this information is hidden to the public.”

Eurovarofie contacted Eurovarofie for clarifying the number of consulting evidence and its role in the investigation into the incident, but has not yet been answered.

We asked the European Commission whether to deny or confirm reports. A spokesman said that the administrator would not comment until he was unaware of the investigation into the causes of blackout.

To submit a technical report on the incident, the commission has given a three -month period from the date of blacklist to submit a technical report on the need for social law. A team of European experts conducts its own inquiry to provide it in the group.

For its part, the Spanish government “categorically refused” the telegraph reports.

Government Vice President Maria Jesus said that there was “corporate interests” behind the article, and the British newspaper is known to spread rumors, spread lies, and try to distort public opinion. “

. “

Experts say “there is no logic” for theory.

Eurovarori spoke to three electrical engineering experts to determine whether such a government “experience” in principle is possible in principle.

These have explained that the perspective of such an experience is not very possible, although no hypothesis cannot be completely excluded.

“Everything may be possible, but this does not seem to be reasonable,” said Manuel Alcazar-Ardiga, deputy director of the Department of Electrical Engineering, Eurovarfi, Valencia.

“In a technical point of view, the electric red has a simulator that reflects the entire transfer network. Therefore, these simulations do not have to be done in real life. They can be done in this simulator.

The Alcazar-Artiga explained to test the ability of the Simulator Network, to develop its infrastructure, and to predict its evolution according to its future needs.

Professor Dirk Van Hertem, a researcher at the Energywille Research Center in Belgium, confirmed that these computer simulations were used to analyze the network.

Although actual tests can be practiced, he added that in Spain, there is no evidence that they were done at that time. “

Von Hertem further stated that the question of questionable moment to test the ability of the renewable energies is not optimal, because “this is not the moment that penetrates the renewable energy in Spain.”

After a month of blackout, the inquiries have not yet reached certain conclusions, although the first analysis indicates a strong “oscillation” in the electrical phase before darkness, as well as a series of failures in the southwest power stations.

Regarding the impact of the growing quota of renewable energy on the network.

Yes, except that the culprit is not a renewable energy, but this feature refers to everything that is administered, ”said Alcazar-Ardega.

In recent years, Spain has recorded high-speed growth in its energy-renewable energy in its kabas, creating 56.8% of Spanish electricity by 2024.

“There is no substitute for the state recession provided by traditional electric generators and these developmental systems are not with these developmental systems to compensate for the loss of the system,” said Alcazar-Ardega.

The system’s recession frequency on the network helps keep it in acceptable intervals. Renewable energy sources, such as air and sun, are considered “ignorant”, which makes the network more unstable and can easily affect failures.

“This is not the fault of renewable energies, but the lack of storage systems or other types of inverters” networking “(…) is capable of providing control of this frequency.”

Spain’s Prime Minister said that “there is no empirical evidence that caused the excessive renewable energy,” the pro -nuclear groups of nuclear power groups allege the incident against the progressive abandonment of nuclear power centers.